Introduction
In today’s busy lifestyle, obtaining sufficient fiber from food alone is a difficult challenge. That’s why Metamucil and Benefiber-like fibers exist and become beneficial for you. Both are popular and effective options, but which one is right for you?
In this blog post, we will break down the difference between Metamucil and Benefiber on the basis of taste, texture, and types etc. That’s will help you in taking decision which is best for you.
What is Benefiber?
Benefiber is a fiber supplement which is made from wheat dextrin. It is natural soluble fiber. It has no flavour, means tasteless, grit-free and completely dissolvable in liquid. Makes it easy to mix it with water, coffee, smoothies or food without changing their taste or texture.
Key Features of Benefiber
- Active Ingredient: Wheat dextrin
- Type of Fiber: Soluble
- No taste and colorless
- It can be added to hot or cold food and drinks
- It is suitable for daily use

What is Metamucil?
Metamucil is also a fiber supplement. from Psyllium Husk it is made. Psyllium is a plant-based natural source of soluble fiber. Comparison to Benefiber, Metamucil has a distinct flavour and texture. It also offers additional benefits such as helping in appetite control and cholesterol management.
Key features of Metamucil
- Active ingredient: Psyllium Husk
- Type of Fiber: Soluble (with some insoluble fiber)
- Orange or berry-flavored options are available
- Helps in lowering cholesterol levels
- It can promote a feeling of fullness

Comparison: Metamucil vs Benefiber
Features | Benefiber | Metamucil |
Main Ingredient | Wheat dextrin | Psyllium Husk |
Type of Fiber | Soluble | Soluble + some insoluble |
Taste | Tasteless | Flavored (orange, berry, etc.) |
Texture | Smooth, dissolves easily | Slightly gritty |
Helps With | Regularity | Regularity, cholesterol, appetite control |
Suitable for low FODMAP | Yes | No |
Calories per serving | Low | Slightly Higher |
Metamucil vs Benefiber: Pros and Cons
Benefiber Pros
- It is Easy to mix with any food or drink
- No taste or texture issues
- It is Great choice for the people with sensitive stomachs
Benefiber Cons
- It Does not help with lowering cholesterol level
- It is Less effective for appetite control
Metamucil Pros
- Helps in lowering the cholesterol
- Helps in appetite Control
- It Promotes a feeling of fullness
Metamucil Cons
- Can be gritty
- Strong taste may not suit to everyone
- May cause bloating in some people
Which one Should You Choose?
Choose Benefiber if you want a gentle, tasteless fiber that is easy to fit into any diet
Choose Metamucil if you are looking for additional health benefits like reducing cholesterol level and control appetite and you don not mind taste and texture
NOTE: Always consult your doctor before adding any fiber supplement in your diet, especially if you have any digestive problem or taking any other medication
FAQs
Can I take both Benefiber and Metamucil together?
In general, it is safe to use both, but best is taking only one and monitor how body reacts. Consult your doctor if you are considering both.
How quickly do Benefiber and Metamucil work?
Both of them showing results within 12 to 72 hours but full effect takes some day-and-consistent use.
Are there any side effects after using Benefiber and Metamucil?
Both of the supplements can cause gas and bloating initially. Always start with a low dose & gradually increase it.
Can fiber supplements help with weight loss?
Fiber is helpful in supporting weight management by promoting fullness. Metamucil has properties to control appetite.
Is it safe to take fiber supplement daily?
Yes, generally daily use of fiber is safe. But it is best to get much of the fiber from natural food resources.
Conclusion
Both Metamucil and Benefiber are effective fiber supplements. These have their own benefits. Your choice depends on your health, diet, and how your body reacts.